From the van, a six-minute read
The short version
1
Under ten years old and the part still made? Fix it.
2
Failed its service twice in a year? Start saving for a new one.
3
Either way, have the flue checked before the first frost.
The long version
Most boilers we are called to are not finished. A diverter valve, a fan or a printed circuit board fails, the part costs less than a tenth of a new boiler, and we can fit it the same week. If the maker still lists the part and the heat exchanger is sound, mending it is the cheaper winter.
Age matters less than people think. A well-serviced boiler of twelve can outlast a neglected one of six, and the service history tells us more than the date on the badge.
The sign we watch for is repetition. One fault in a year is bad luck; two, on different parts, usually means the rest of the boiler is wearing out at the same rate, and the money is better saved towards a replacement than spent a part at a time.
Whatever you decide, have the flue looked at before the cold arrives. It is a ten-minute check, it is the part of the job that keeps you safe, and it is the one most often skipped.